Administrative fine - definition
An administrative fine is a monetary penalty imposed by a data protection supervisory authority for an infringement of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). The legal basis is primarily Article 83 GDPR. A fine is not automatic after every infringement. The authority must assess the circumstances of the specific processing activity and determine whether a fine is effective, proportionate, and dissuasive.
For image and video processing, an administrative fine may result from unlawful collection, retention, disclosure, or insufficient protection of footage in which people can be identified. Video footage containing identifiable faces is generally personal data. A face that has been irreversibly anonymized so that identification is no longer reasonably likely is outside the GDPR, subject to the assessment in Recital 26 GDPR.
Administrative fines can apply to organizations that operate cameras, receive footage from customers, provide video-processing services, or determine how face and license plate data are handled. They can also apply to processors where the processor breaches obligations directly imposed by the GDPR.
Fine levels under Article 83 GDPR
Article 83 establishes two maximum tiers. The applicable ceiling depends on the provisions infringed. The ceiling is a legal maximum, not a standard amount. For an undertaking, the percentage of worldwide annual turnover may produce a higher amount than the fixed euro amount.
Maximum fine tier | Relevant GDPR provisions | Maximum amount | Examples in video monitoring |
|---|---|---|---|
Lower tier | Articles 8, 11, 25-39, 42, and 43 GDPR | Up to €10 million or up to 2% of total worldwide annual turnover for the preceding financial year, whichever is higher | No appropriate data protection by design, inadequate processor contract, insufficient security controls, or failure to conduct a required Data Protection Impact Assessment |
Higher tier | Articles 5, 6, 7, 9, 12-22, and 44-49 GDPR | Up to €20 million or up to 4% of total worldwide annual turnover for the preceding financial year, whichever is higher | Footage collected without a lawful basis, excessive retention, invalid consent, inadequate privacy information, unlawful international transfer, or disregard of data subject rights |
These limits are set by Article 83(4) and 83(5) GDPR. Where multiple infringements arise from the same or linked processing operations, Article 83(3) provides that the total fine must not exceed the maximum for the gravest infringement.
How supervisory authorities calculate an administrative fine
Article 83(2) GDPR lists factors that each supervisory authority must consider. The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) explains a four-step approach in its Guidelines 04/2022 on the calculation of administrative fines under the GDPR, version 2.1, adopted on May 24, 2023.
- Identify the processing operations and determine whether they form one or several cases.
- Identify the infringements and determine the applicable legal maximum.
- Assess the seriousness of the infringement, including its nature, gravity, duration, intent or negligence, affected data subjects, and categories of personal data.
- Adjust the amount for aggravating and mitigating factors, while ensuring that the final fine remains effective, proportionate, and dissuasive.
Relevant mitigating factors can include prompt containment, meaningful cooperation with the authority, and documented technical and organizational measures. Repeated noncompliance, deliberate processing, failure to follow an authority's order, or financial benefit from the infringement can increase the amount.
Typical monitoring and anonymization failures
Camera and video workflows often create several GDPR risks at once. The issue is not limited to whether faces are blurred. Organizations must assess the full lifecycle of footage, from collection and storage through access, export, sharing, anonymization, and deletion.
- No lawful basis: recording visitors, employees, customers, or passersby without identifying an appropriate Article 6 GDPR lawful basis.
- Disproportionate monitoring: using cameras where less intrusive measures would meet the stated purpose, or recording areas unrelated to that purpose.
- Insufficient transparency: failing to provide clear camera notices and the information required by Articles 12-14 GDPR.
- Excessive retention: retaining identifiable footage longer than necessary, contrary to the storage limitation principle in Article 5(1)(e) GDPR.
- Weak access control: allowing broad access to original footage, unprotected exports, or shared folders containing identifiable video.
- Incomplete risk assessment: failing to conduct a Data Protection Impact Assessment under Article 35 GDPR where systematic monitoring creates a likely high risk to individuals.
- Inadequate anonymization: distributing video after incomplete masking, where faces or license plates remain identifiable in individual frames, reflections, motion blur, or missed detections.
Administrative fines and face or license plate blurring
Face detection and license plate detection can support data minimization when footage must be shared for training, incident review, research, publication, or supplier access. However, blurring is not a substitute for a lawful basis, transparency, retention controls, or security measures. A blurred copy may reduce risk, while the original footage remains personal data and must still be governed under the GDPR.
Organizations should validate anonymization before external disclosure. Relevant checks include detection recall, false-negative rate, review of scene changes, frame-by-frame verification of fast movement, and confirmation that source files and exports are stored separately. A missed face or license plate can leave a person identifiable and may undermine a claim that the shared footage is anonymized.
Gallio PRO processes stored images and video files rather than real-time video streams. Its automatic processing covers faces and license plates. Company logos, tattoos, name badges, documents, and monitor content require manual masking with the built-in editor. These limits should be included in the organization’s review procedure and risk assessment.
Legal basis and guidance under EU law
Administrative fines are governed by Articles 58 and 83 GDPR. Article 58 gives supervisory authorities corrective powers, including warnings, reprimands, orders to comply, processing restrictions, and fines. A fine can therefore be combined with an order to stop processing, delete footage, improve security, or meet a data subject request.
The principal sources for video-monitoring compliance are:
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679, especially Articles 5, 6, 25, 32, 35, 58, and 83, and Recitals 26, 74-77, and 148.
- EDPB Guidelines 3/2019 on processing of personal data through video devices, version 2.0, adopted January 29, 2020.
- EDPB Guidelines 04/2022 on the calculation of administrative fines under the GDPR, version 2.1, adopted May 24, 2023.
US equivalent
The United States has no single federal equivalent to the GDPR administrative-fine system for all image and video processing. Enforcement is sectoral and state-specific. Depending on the facts, comparable exposure may arise under state privacy laws such as the California Consumer Privacy Act, as amended by the California Privacy Rights Act, biometric privacy laws such as Illinois’ Biometric Information Privacy Act, consumer-protection enforcement by the Federal Trade Commission, or specialized federal rules.
Unlike Article 83 GDPR, US penalties do not follow one universal percentage-of-turnover framework. Requirements for blurring faces or license plates also vary by state, public-records law, contract, platform policy, and court practice.