What is the right to erasure?

Right to erasure - definition

The right to erasure is a data subject right under Article 17 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), applicable since 25 May 2018. It is often called the “right to be forgotten”, but Article 17 is broader and more technical. It gives an identified or identifiable natural person the right to require a controller to erase personal data in defined situations.

Article 17(1) GDPR states that the data subject has the right to obtain from the controller “the erasure of personal data concerning him or her without undue delay” where one of the legal grounds applies. In image and video processing, this can mean deleting a recording, removing selected frames, or irreversibly anonymizing the person’s face and other relevant identifiers so that the person is no longer identifiable from the footage.

For privacy and compliance teams, the key point is that erasure does not always require destruction of the whole video file. If the organization still needs the recording for a lawful purpose, for example security review, accident investigation, legal defense, or documentation of property damage, anonymization may be an appropriate way to execute the request. The anonymization must be effective. Simple cosmetic blurring that can be reversed or bypassed is not enough.

When Article 17 GDPR applies to video footage

Article 17 GDPR applies only if the video or image contains personal data. A face is personal data when a person is identified or identifiable. A license plate may also be personal data when it can be linked to a person, for example through vehicle registration data or operational records.

Article 17 ground

Meaning for recorded images and video

Data is no longer necessary

The recording is no longer needed for the purpose for which it was collected, such as site security or incident handling.

Consent is withdrawn

The footage was processed on consent, and no other legal basis remains.

Successful objection

The person objects under Article 21 GDPR, and the controller has no overriding legitimate grounds, or the person objects to processing for direct marketing under Article 21(2) GDPR.

Unlawful processing

The footage was captured or retained without a valid legal basis or beyond a lawful retention period.

Legal obligation to erase

European Union or Member State law requires erasure. Effective anonymization may suffice only if it removes the personal data and the law does not specifically require destruction.

Information society services offered to a child

The personal data was collected in relation to the offer of information society services referred to in Article 8(1) GDPR.

The controller must also assess Article 17(3) GDPR. Erasure may be refused or limited where processing is necessary for freedom of expression and information, compliance with a legal obligation, public interest in public health, archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research, statistical purposes, or the establishment, exercise, or defense of legal claims.

Anonymization as a way to execute the right to erasure

In video workflows, anonymization can implement erasure when it removes the personal data from the retained file. This is consistent with Recital 26 GDPR, which says that data protection principles do not apply to anonymous information, meaning information that does not relate to an identified or identifiable natural person.

For a face in a recording, practical erasure can involve irreversible masking of the face across all frames in which the person appears. For a vehicle, it can involve irreversible masking of the license plate. Gallio PRO supports automatic detection and blurring of faces and license plates in stored image and video files. It does not perform real-time anonymization or video stream anonymization.

A compliant workflow should define the erasure object precisely. It should also preserve evidence of the decision without creating new personal data risks.

  1. Identify the requester and the relevant footage.
  2. Verify whether the person appears in the footage.
  3. Check whether Article 17(1) applies and whether Article 17(3) prevents erasure.
  4. Decide whether full deletion or anonymization is the correct execution method.
  5. Mask the relevant face or license plate in every applicable frame.
  6. Review the output for missed detections, reflections, thumbnails, previews, and exported copies.
  7. Record the legal decision, processing date, operator, and file reference.

Gallio PRO does not collect logs containing face or license plate detections. It also does not collect logs containing personal or sensitive data. This is relevant when designing an erasure process because operational audit records should not recreate the personal data that the organization has just removed.

Technical controls for erasure in images and video

Effective anonymization requires more than applying a visible blur to a single frame. The controller should be able to show that the person is no longer identifiable in the resulting material, taking account of available technology and likely means of re-identification, as reflected in Recital 26 GDPR.

Control

Compliance purpose

Practical check

Frame coverage

Ensures the person is masked for the full time they appear.

Review beginning, end, occlusion, reflection, and motion blur segments.

Irreversibility

Prevents recovery of the original face or license plate.

Export a flattened anonymized file, not an editable project with original pixels visible.

Object scope

Matches the erasure request to the data subject.

Mask the requester and avoid unnecessary masking of unrelated persons unless required.

Residual identifiers

Reduces re-identification risk from context.

Check voice, clothing, location, timestamp, and unusual events separately.

Automatic blurring in Gallio PRO covers faces and license plates only. The software does not automatically detect company logos, tattoos, name badges, documents, or content displayed on monitors. These elements can be blurred in manual mode using the built-in editor when they create an identification risk in a specific recording.

Response time and documentation

Article 12(3) GDPR sets the response deadline. The controller must provide information on action taken without undue delay and in any event within one month of receipt of the request. This period may be extended by two further months where necessary, taking account of the complexity and number of requests. The controller must inform the data subject of the extension and the reasons for the delay within one month.

For video erasure requests, useful internal records include the request date, identity verification method, legal basis assessment, footage identifiers, retention reason, anonymization method, quality review result, and response date. These records support accountability under Article 5(2) GDPR without retaining unnecessary copies of the original footage.

The main legal source is Article 17 GDPR, read with Articles 12, 15, 21, and 5 GDPR. Recital 65 explains the policy basis for erasure where retention infringes the GDPR. Recital 66 addresses erasure where personal data has been made public. Recital 26 is central for anonymization because it explains when data is no longer related to an identifiable person.

The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) Guidelines 3/2019 on processing of personal data through video devices, version 2.0 adopted on 29 January 2020, address video surveillance, data subject rights, retention, and masking of third parties. The Article 29 Working Party Opinion 05/2014 on Anonymisation Techniques, adopted on 10 April 2014, remains a widely cited EU reference for assessing singling out, linkability, and inference risks in anonymized data.

US equivalent

There is no single United States federal equivalent to Article 17 GDPR for all image and video footage. The closest broad state-law comparison is the right to delete personal information under the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018, as amended by the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020, codified at California Civil Code section 1798.105. Sectoral laws may also provide amendment, retention, or disposal duties in specific contexts, such as health records under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), but they do not create a general video erasure right equivalent to Article 17 GDPR.

See also